Grill Mats Reviewed

by steve

Grilling is a living and a way of life for me. I love every aspect of barbecuing, mostly because of the challenges and the unforeseen obstacles that can occur on a regular basis. One of the biggest challenges everyone encounters is trying to not lose those smaller items your grilling through your grill grates. Luckily for us there are products to help us with this very challenge.

I was sent a sample to review called Frogmats that’s designed to prevent smaller food items from falling through your grill grates. Here’s some background information & benefits for the Frogmats:


We have all experienced the frustration of grilling delicate foods on the BBQ. The food immediately sticks to the grates and tears or crumbles when you try to turn it. The food falls through the openings in the grate and you have one big mess. Frogmats solve this problem. Food will not stick to the Frogmats and is easy to turn without crumbing. Frogmats are great for preparing fish and Ka Bobs. Fish will lift off the Frogmats with ease as does the vegetables in Ka Bobs. The open matrix of the Frogmats will eliminate to a large degree any food from falling through the grates. The Frogmats will not pick up odors from fish; therefore each time it is used there will be no leftover taste. Frogmats are designed to perform in indirect cooking methods. Do not expose the Frogmats to direct flame. Our Frogmats are FDA compliant for direct food contact. These are easy to clean with a warm water spray by the outdoor hose or in the kitchen with sink sprayer. The Frogmats will last for years.

After receiving the Frogmats, a few days later, I found another product called Grill-O-Sheet at one of those big hardware box stores that was similar to the Frogmats. Here’s some background info & benefits for the Grill-O-Sheet:


With the Grill-O-Sheet you’ll always have a clean cooking surface. It will keep food from falling through your grill grates. You can eat healthy fish and veggies delicious from the grill. The Grill-O-Sheet will cook your food evenly. It’s reusable and can be used several times over. It’s also dishwasher safe.

So as you can see, both products pretty much claim to give you the same benefits so I was eager to try these two grill mats to see which one would be the better of the two products. I purchased the Grill-O-Sheet and decided that I’d do a head-to-head comparison test on both grill mats.

The meat, equipment and settings to be used:

  • Chicken Wings
  • Backwoods Smoker Professional Model
  • Maintained temperature between 230° and 235°
  • Used a combination of oak and hickory wood

Testing Procedure

Both mats were loaded into the smoker at the same time with the internal smoker temperature at 238 degrees. As I checked on the progress, the Grill O-Sheet appeared to be cooking the food faster, though it was unevenly cooking the food. However, the Frogmats were lagging behind in the cooking department though that allowed the food to cook more evenly.


The wings on the Grill-O-Sheet finished in approximately 75 minutes with an internal temperature of 165 degrees. I attribute the fast cooking time due to the fact the Grill-O-Sheets are made out of aluminum which is a heat conductor.


The wings on the Frogmats were a little more than halfway cooked at the time I removed the test wings on the Grill-O-Sheet. After just under 2½ hours, I removed the wings that were on the Frogmats so you can see the discrepancy in cooking time for these grill mats.

Here’s what I learned from this head-to-head comparison testing:

Frogmats ★★★★½

Frogmats Pros:

  • It is 10”x13” in size and only costs $8.99 + shipping & handling.
  • The wings were evenly covered with color and took on a nice smoke flavor.
  • It was easy to clean & could do so in a matter of a minute or less.
  • It’s very durable and should last you for many uses.
  • The holes in the mat are smaller totally eliminating loss of food between the grill grates.
  • It’s able to be rolled up for butts or roasts.
  • It can be cut to size with standard scissors.

Frogmats Cons:

  • It has a smaller cooking surface, although they’re possibly available in different sizes.
  • It’s for indirect cooking only.
  • Its cooking time was longer, but this isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

Grill-O-Sheet ★★★½☆

Grill-O-Sheet Pros:

  • You get 2 sheets that are 12”x20” in size and only cost $6.99.
  • It can be used for both direct and indirect cooking.
  • It’s able to be rolled up for butts or roasts.
  • It can be cut to size with standard scissors.

Grill-O-Sheet Cons:

  • The cooking time was too fast, compromising quality in color, smoke and tenderness.
  • It doesn’t clean as easily as the company claims. It took some hard scrubbing to get all the skin off of it.
  • It’s actually only good for a couple of uses and then you have to dispose of them.

Our Conclusion

If you’re a every once-in-a-while backyard griller or just need a grill mat that you can just throw out afterwards, Grill-O-Sheet would get the vote for which one to choose ONLY due to its cheaper price. However, if it were me, I would still use Frogmats no matter what due to how superior they were to the Grill-O-Sheet based on our tests.

We rated the Frogmats hands down the better buy than Grill-O-Sheet as it is far superior in all categories. Even the extra time the wings on the Frogmats spent on the smoker was well worth the wait. They had great color, incredible smoke flavor and by far those wings were the tenderest to the bite.

Happy Queing,

The Que Dude

Previous post:

Next post: